Pizza Bracket Results: Meet the Rest of the Original 32

Meet the Rest of the Original 32
Pizza Challlenge, Photo By Roberto Gonzalez


1803 Pizza Kitchen

Named for their address on Winter Park Road, this neighborhood spot has garnered rave reviews for their varied pizza menu, which includes vegan options. Save room for their tempting roster of desserts as well—the Brownie Bombon is a favorite.

Anthony’s Pizza (Casselberry)

A fixture on 17-92 in Casselberry since 1988, Anthony’s specializes in New York-style pizza, but also offers a myriad of styles, from tomato pies and stuffed pizzas to Sicilian-style as well as calzones and stromboli. A number of their most popular specialties are available by the slice as well.


Specializing in Neapolitan cuisine, Armando’s takes special pride in their pizza. While you can’t go wrong with a simple Margherita, lovers of sweet and savory will be tempted by the Prosciutto E Fichi featuring prosciutto, fig jam and gorgonzola. Three locations in Winter Park, College Park and Lake Nona.

Bella Italia Pizza

Located in the Conway area, this neighborhood favorite serves up a wide variety of specialty pizzas, including the Eggplant Rollatini featuring eggplant and ricotta cheese, and a Cheesesteak Pizza with steak, onions and peppers. For a portable take on your favorite dish, check out the Pizza Sub.

Blaze Pizza

Blaze Fast Fire’d pizzas come to you in a flash, thanks to their super-hot ovens. Select from specialties or create your own on their assembly line, and have your pie in 180 seconds. Three locations, in Winter Park and Disney Springs and across from UCF.

Boardwalk Pizza

Located on Lake Howell Road in Winter Park, Boardwalk Pizza offers several specialty pies, including a deep dish pan pizza with a crust bathed in garlic butter and herbs. Opt for the Chicken Florentine for a lighter take on a traditional slice.

F&D Woodfired Kitchen

First opened in the Hourglass District in 2018, F&D Woodfired has recently expanded to a second location in Longwood. The Due Carni receives rave reviews, while vegans find a good selection of options made with Beyond plant-based proteins.


This Orlando-based micro chain boasting several locations across Central Florida began in 1987 when founders Scott Kousaie and Todd Dennis opened their first tiny location. Notable specialties include the Hog and Honey, replete with Italian sausage, bacon, roasted red peppers and finished with a drizzle of local raw honey.


Specializing in Brazilian pizza, this local favorite with spots in Orlando and Kissimmee offers its thin-crust pies with an array of traditional Brazilian toppings, from corn and hearts of palm to Catupiry cheese. Save room for their Sweet Pizzas featuring fruit, cheese, chocolate, dulce de leche and more.

The Pizza Press

Don’t let the fun, old-timey newspaper theme fool you: This is delicious pizza. Start at the press at the front, and choose either build-your-own or specialty pies, named for famous American newspapers, such as The Sun, featuring ham, bacon, sharp cheddar, pineapple and more. Don’t skip the Garlic Cheesy Bread, which is basically a white pizza with sauce for dipping. Locations in Celebration and Winter Garden.

Pizzeria Del-Dio

A mainstay of Colonialtown, family owned and operated Pizzeria Del-Dio’s history began in Brooklyn, before the original owners relocated to Florida in 1994. Order a split specialty pizza to please everyone, or opt for the heart-shaped pie to romance your pizza-loving honey.

Retro Station

Prefer your pizza with a side of nostalgia? Then head to Retro Station, the winner of the Readers’ Choice Award for best pizza in our recent Dining Awards. The interior recalls the 1950s while some of the specialty pizzas have a decidedly Brazilian flair. The Portuguesa, for instance, is loaded with tomatoes, black olives, onion, ham and boiled eggs.

Sixty Vines

This new winery-inspired hotspot opened in March, and it’s already making waves in Winter Park. Its emphasis on shareable plates includes wood-fired pizzas featuring elevated combinations such as fig and prosciutto, artichoke and garlic, and more.


College Park locals in the know swear by Tornatore’s and their complete “scratch-made” menu of specialties. Want gluten-free or cauliflower crust for your Diesel or Joe Gibbs Pie? No problem.

Via Napoli

Located at Walt Disney World’s Epcot, Via Napoli strives to provide visitors with an authentic Neapolitan pizza—right down to importing their Caputo flour and Italian spring water! Enjoy watching pizzas bake in the triple ovens, named Stromboli, Vesuvio and Etna.

Vines & Forks

Blink and you might miss Vines & Forks on Fairbanks Avenue in Winter Park. Previously known to most of us as The Wine Barn, the restaurant-inside-a-wine-shop turns out some of our favorite pizzas in Central Florida. While the Piemonte has long been a fan favorite, try the Bacon Mojito with pork belly bacon, peaches, chevre and asiago, drizzled with a rum balsamic glaze during your next visit.


 Our Sins of Omission

The grousing on social media began the minute the 32 pizzerias selected for our Pizza Bracket Challenge were posted. It went something like this:

How in the hell is (fill in the blank) not on there?

Well because we had only 32 slots available to present to readers for their brackets. Next time perhaps we go with 64. Or 128. Or 256.

Seriously, as is the case with the most famous bracket of them all, the March Madness NCAA basketball tournament, some places were left off. In picking the 32, we considered our staff’s assessment (from having actually eaten the pizzas), plus reputation, and the opinions of serious foodies as well as typical diners. Also, we included a few chains, which some folks didn’t care for—but if we had left them off we would have heard about that too.

So allow us to present some of those not selected for the bracket but pizza makers certainly worthy of your patronage, if their vocal fan bases are any indication:

Antica (Altamonte Springs); Goodfella’s, Broadway, Mario’s, Papa Gio’s (all in East Orlando); Rome’s Flavours and Rosati’s (Winter Park); Pizzeria Valdiano (Winter Park and Waterford Lakes); Brick & Fire (SoDo District); Santino’s, Torino’s, North End, Cucinella’s, Café Panuzzo’s (all in Oviedo); Papa Lozzi Italia (Waterford Lakes); Proccolino’s (two locations in East Orlando); Italian House (Hourglass District); Chianti’s (Longwood and Sanford); NY Pizza Baby (Winter Park and Apopka); Destiny’s Big City Pizza (Winter Springs); Capone’s Coal Fired Pizza (Kissimmee); Vinzo’s (Casselberry); Panino’s, Gitto’s , Planet Pizza (all in downtown Orlando); Josie’s (MetroWest and Windermere); Pisa Pizza (West Colonial Drive); Pizza Xtreme (I-Drive area); Joe’s Pizza (Ocoee); Caffe Positano (Apopka); A Slice of NY Pizza  (Hunter’s Creek); Il Pescatore (Colonialtown); MidiCi (Maitland); and Anthony’s (we had three in the bracket but there appear to be about a hundred others in the area).

Okay, okay, we surrender. Next time: bracket of 64.

Well, maybe.

— Barry Glenn

Categories: Home Page Features, News and Features