Courtesy of Summer House
Here’s your cheat sheet to Central Florida’s most coveted Thanksgiving pies! From the award-winning classics at Sister Honey’s to the rich indulgence of Se7enBites and the nostalgic charm of Charlie’s Bakery. Whether you’re eyeing Winter Park Pie Company’s creamy creations, Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream’s frozen twists, or Summer House’s own Pumpkin Chiffon Pie with Chantilly cream, these local favorites make skipping the oven look easy. Just be sure to pre-order; the best pies in town sell out fast.
Difficulty Level: 100
Sister Honey’s
Sister Honey’s pie’s are legendary. Evette Rahman opened Sister Honey’s in 2012 and soon began winning ribbons and accolades for her baking. “Our philosophy,” she says from her SODO-area shop, “is to make a quality product, provide people with something to enjoy. I think to myself: ‘I’ve got to make this right.’ ” This year’s Thanksgiving Pie, a Pumpkin Pecan Streusel Pie, goes on sale November 4 around noon. Orders must be placed on their website, and they sell out quickly.
Difficulty Level: 85
Winter Park Pie Company
From Banana Cream Pie to Pumpkin Pie, Lemon Meringue and Creamy Custard, the Winter Park Pie Company has a plethora of pies for your Thanksgiving feast. This local pie company has no brick and mortar, so you’ll need to arrange delivery in one of their delivery zip codes or pick up a pie in the Winter Park area November 25-26.
Difficulty Level: 70
Charlie’s Bakery and Creamery
Orlando icon Charlie’s Bakery has an incredible selection of desserts to wow your guests. From Parker House Rolls to Pecan Pie, Pumpkin Pie, and more, Charlie’s Bakery and Creamery offers a wide selection of delicious, high quality pies for your Thanksgiving holiday. Orders must be in by November 20.
Difficulty Level: 70
Buttermilk Bakery
Although Buttermilk Bakery hasn’t yet disclosed their Thanksgiving pie menu or schedule, be on the lookout for updates on their website and Instagram.
Difficulty Level: 50
Se7enBites
Se7enBites‘ consistency and rich flavors will make this the star of your Thanksgiving meal. This year, Trina is offering:
- 9” double crusted Salted Caramel Dark Chocolate Pecan Pie $70
- 9” Mile High Pumpkin Pie $65
- 9” Cranberry Apple Cointreau Galette $60
- 8” Hummingbird Cake w/Cream Cheese Buttercream & Toasted Pecans
They will also be offering mini individual size of these 3 pies sold in sets of 6 for $48 or 12 – $96 (mix & match). Se7enBites is taking orders now through Thursday November 20 at 3:00 p.m.
Difficulty Level: 50
Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream
Try something different and order an ice cream pie from Kelly’s Homemade Ice Cream this year. Choose from 8″ Pumpkin Cheesecake or 8″ Peanut Butter Pie. Each pie serves approximately 6 people. Preorder now for pick-up in-store November 24-26.
Difficulty Level: 50
Summer House on the Lake
Located in Disney Springs, Summer House on the Lake is offering homemade Pumpkin Chiffon Pie from Summer House on the Lake for your Thanksgiving celebration. For $39.95, plus tax, the pie serves six and features a flaky graham cracker crust and vanilla Chantilly cream. Gluten-free option available upon request. Pre-order 24 hours prior to intended pick-up, which is available Monday, November 24 – Wednesday, November 26 from 9:00 a.m. – 3:00 p.m.