Bookmark and Share Email this page Email Print this page Print

Rope-A-Dope or Going for Broke?

    The Rumble in the Jungle was a boxing event between Muhammad Ali and George Foreman. Foreman was favored to win the fight because he was a more powerful puncher. During the match, Ali did his best to anger Foreman, who then attacked him relentlessly because of it. He forced Ali into the ropes. Ali looked beaten and many in the boxing world believed it. However, the fight was far from over – it was a successful strategy. Instead of being brutalized, he protected himself by allowing his sparring partners to beat him silly while training for the fight, and when Foreman got tired from all the punches he threw, Ali rebounded and won. That boxing style became known as the rope-a-dope.
    Is this what's happening today in the Casey Anthony courtroom? Is the defense allowing the state to think they're up against a weak challenger? Don't count on it. From my ringside seat, enough time has elapsed to evaluate the situation, and I think it's safe to say we can sense the approach each side is taking. The way I see it, the prosecution is like a championship prizefighter, but without the rope-a-dope strategy.
    The defense, on the other hand, looks like a young upstart. The style is combative and unorthodox, but that doesn't always mean ineffective. A champion looks at someone new as an unknown entity and doesn't know what to expect. In this case, I would consider Jose Baez a fighter, but I would not consider him an extraordinary one. While he's got a rough and tumble trainer in Cheney Mason, sort of like Mickey Goldmill, Burgess Meredith's character in Rocky, Jose is no Rocky, although some of his ideas play out like a fictional character. No, I see him more as someone who has his moments, but not enough that we will ever see the state attorneys backed into a corner by any “float like a butterfly, sting like a bee” trickery. Let's face it, the defense has an awful challenge ahead, but are they a good match?
    When Jose practically called George Anthony an incestuous pervert for sexually abusing his daughter from age 8 until 13, he was laying a foundation for later on. It's the same thing with the pool story; that George was the one who pulled Caylee's lifeless body out of the water. Things like that are called gut punches, but Jose's are unfairly hitting below the belt.
    Like the rounds of a boxing match, the state is taking us on a well-choreographed journey that began on June 15, 2008, the day before Caylee died. It leads to Casey's arrest on the first-degree capital murder charge and beyond – the discovery of her daughter's skeletal remains in the woods around the corner from her house. Everything is meticulously in order; everything falls neatly into place because it's being presented at a pace that has time to sink in, and that helps the jury piece things together nicely. The defense, on the other hand, attempts to unhinge the work. Have they been successful?
    Every witness called to the stand so far has kept the defense off balance. Oh, they've had a few zingers, but most have been mea culpa moments. Every one of Casey's former friends and lovers from Anthony Lazzaro to Amy Huizenga have told a similar story about Casey that pits the good against the bad. George Anthony did extremely well on the stand and Cindy fared better, although it must have been one of the worst days in her life. She was great, and by the time we finished listening to the third 911 call, you could have heard a pin drop in the courtroom. It was riveting and powerful, to say the least. Amy made Jose look terrible. When he accused her of being a drunk in order to discredit her, she told him outright that she was not on trial here. Nor was she a hussy for getting to know Jesse Grund, Casey's former beau. Nope, she fell for nothing. I understand that a defense attorney throws everything, including the kitchen sink, at the opposition, but she was one sharp lady.
    When Jose brought up Casey's menagerie of friends, like Zenaida Fernandez-Gonzalez, he took an interesting twist by facing the problem head on. He questioned Cindy about why she never sensed that Casey was living in another world, a world with very realistic imaginary people. He tried to infer that Yuri was a novice for not recognizing these friends for what they really are – fictional figments from an obviously disturbed individual. In almost all instances, Jose came across as a bumbler. Lazzaro, Huizenga and all her former party mates came across as very credible. Yuri reminded me of an old Sade song – Smooth Operator.
    Ultimately, the bottom line is this:
  • No one is ever going to believe that George sexually abused his own daughter.
  • When George came home on the fateful night of July 15, 2008, he was just as confused as everyone else in that household. Clearly, he understood from many past experiences the out of control wrath of his daughter, and instead of instigating the problem, he let law enforcement do their jobs.
  • As for George finding Caylee in the pool, it won't work. He would have called 911 -- hands down.
The story making the rounds in and near the courthouse is pretty much set in concrete now. When Cindy Anthony found out what the defense strategy was going to be, and yes, she did, she stopped searching for the imaginary nanny. While she and George both knew that an abuse allegation was on its way, they had absolutely no idea how far it would go. George, Cindy and Lee, plus their attorney, were as shocked as we were. Trust me, I know all about the low blows this defense is capable of throwing, and so does one of the Ninth Circuit Court's finest.
    Once again, throw everything at the wall and something's bound to stick. While the state of Florida doesn't consider Casey psychologically challenged, the jury may. Personally, I think she is, and what Jose is proposing is preposterous, but it may be enough to keep her off death row. Why? Let's see, there's Zenaida and Jeff and Zachary and Gloria and Samantha and Juliet and Raquel and Jules. Surely, the state of Florida would never execute that many narcissistic sociopaths at one time.






Please limit comments to the blog's subject matter. Comments containing profanity and/or personal attacks will not be published.

Old to new | New to old
Comments, page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4  ··· 7 Next »
Jun 2, 2011 05:33 am
 Posted by  Marsha from NY

Great article as usual Dave. Keep up the fair and balanced reporting!!! Picture of you and Ashleigh was great.
Marsha from NY

Jun 2, 2011 06:01 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

Hey Dave! Verna from fb here. Another awesome article. I was thinking kinda the dame thing about thr jury and them thinking Casey is nuts. If nothing else, the defense has established rrsonable doubt. This is not playing out as I had hoped. I do have faith in our justice system, and I believe Casey will get her punishment. I have to. Thanks for having coffee with me again this morning. I love the company. You're the best and the first place I go for news on justice for Caylee. Keep it up, I need you. :)

Jun 2, 2011 06:03 am
 Posted by  Peggy

WOW WOW WOW Dave, what an extraordinary amazing and very well informed article. You have nailed the defense just where they are, maybe not down for the count but getting closer.

My heart broke for Cindy, she was as defeated as she could possible be. As hard as that was on her, I hope she knows that she was finally and hopefully getting Justice for Caylee. Her precious granddaughter was looking down on her and helping her through her testimony. I was suprised, why I do not know, how angry Casey was on Saturday after Cindy testified. Did she honesty think that she Cindy would do nothing to help the State, apparently so.

Amy was such a good witness, she would not fall for Jose and his endless questions of her past.

Jose is way out of his league, he will never be as good as he thinks he is. This trial needs a seasoned attorney, not someone that can only ask questions that the State has not introduced as evidence. How many times does Judge Perry have to tell him the same thing day after day? I wonder what Judge Perry thinks of him as an attorney. Casey's life is on the line and he is not helping her one bit. Mr. Mason was more verbal yesterday, perhaps some shifting is being done.

Again Dave, absolutely incredible article, thank you.

Jun 2, 2011 06:17 am
 Posted by  Dave Knechel

Hi Marsha - Thank you. I must say I am a bit biased, though. It's not all bad for the defense. For instance, the general consensus in the gallery upstairs was that Baez was well within his rights to try to impeach Yuri Melich. He is, after all, supposed to protect his client. Also, by nipping in the bud that Casey is a liar was a good move. Plus, if he can convince the jury Casey has some serious psychological problems, which she does, he may gain some sympathy.

You are correct about the picture. Without Ashley, I would have looked far from great.

Jun 2, 2011 06:35 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

The only champ in this courtroom who can "float like a butterfly and sting like a bee" is the most Honorable Belvin Perry, he remains the undefeated champ.

Keep up the good work, Dave!


Jun 2, 2011 06:40 am
 Posted by  Dave Knechel

Hi Verna! Thank you. Personally, the defense strategy that the defense has proposed was a good move. I have a lot of faith in that jury, too. Ultimately, they will have to decide whether she knew what she was doing. Obviously, she knew right from wrong, but she's got some serious mental issues.

Jun 2, 2011 06:43 am
 Posted by  nan11

This was a great post, Dave. Although I'm finding this far from humorous, I even chuckled at your ending.

The thing that bothers me is that it has been obvious from the beginning that Miss Anthony has 'mental' problems-why would her defense wait almost three years to admit it?

They finally decided to grab the "something is just not right" theory; sandwich it between sexual abuse and accidental death and toss it out to the jury.

What took them so long? Maybe it's the duct tape.

Jun 2, 2011 06:44 am
 Posted by  Dave Knechel

Hi Peggy - I think Casey realized on Saturday that her family was not going to give her what she's always gotten. That's enabled her over the years, but now, it's finished. That's what hit her on the head.

I have to leave for the courthouse now, but thank you very much.

To everyone... I can't login on my iPad, so I will be back tonight to respond. I think it's a proxy issue.

Jun 2, 2011 06:52 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

Hi Dave

Tiffany, one of your avid readers from Australia here. I almost dozed off during testimony for day 18, im a bit over Casey being on trial for her lies and am wondering if and when we will get to the nitty gritty of this murder trial. The defense has a monumental challenge ahead of them, that is where my sympathy lays squarely for today.

A double life, chronic lying, alleged sexual abuse, theft, front temporal lobe problems, promiscuity, family dysfunction, denial... there is so much about Casey that is difficult to understand. What happened to this girl do you think Dave? I can't even fathom the psychology.

Jun 2, 2011 07:32 am
 Posted by  Anonymous

Great story, it makes a world of difference in understanding, when you relate the trial to a real life event.
While the Defense is throwing too many punches below the belt, the referee (Judge Perry) intervenes and calls fowl, but it is already too late, the audience (Jurors)already saw it, the prosecution was injured. You cannot take back the punch, nor can you un-ring the bell.
While questioning Yuri, Baez read Casey's hand written report where she said she went to a "safe place". Then, Baez kept saying to Yuri numerous times, "not safe at home". It was never stated Casey was not safe at home. I don't know why the prosecution did not object to this.

Comments, page 1 of 7 1 2 3 4  ··· 7 Next »
Add your comment:
Edit Module

About This Blog

'Marinade Dave' Knechel

Dave Knechel has been blogging about the Casey Anthony case since late 2008, drawing readers from all over the world. Best known as “Marinade Dave,” a nickname he got when he made marinades and also blogged about marinade recipes, Knechel is on assignment to blog about the case exclusively for as Anthony goes to trial for first-degree murder. His posts will appear regularly on this site.

Recent Posts



Atom Feed Subscribe to the Casey Anthony Trial Feed »